Insights
Firm News

Federal Circuit Rebuke of PTAB Interpretation May Aid Patentees

October 6, 2017 Media Coverage

Law360
October 6, 2017

"Federal Circuit Rebuke of PTAB Interpretation May Aid Patentees"

Jim Day commented on the Federal Circuit's decision scolding the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) for using an "unreasonably broad" reading of a patent.

In the article, Jim said the lines from the Federal Circuit's opinion about tying claim construction to the specification will be useful to litigants arguing that patent claims should be read narrowly. "Whoever it is who wants to say patent claims are narrow now has a really nice statement," he said. "This is a pretty good quote if you want to make that argument."

However, he added, the decision’s focus on the specification seems to be at odds with typical claim construction principles. "The specification is supposed to give an example of what the invention looks like, and the claims define how broad the patent is," Mr. Day said. "The reading in this decision sounds inconsistent with that to me. It sounds like the specification is going to define the scope of the claims."

Mr. Day said the decision appears to be an effort by the Federal Circuit to clarify the complex task of interpreting patent claims. "In claim construction, there’s a risk of an 'eye of the beholder’ situation, where whoever reads a patent has an idea of what it means," he said. "Here we see judges trying to bring some order to it."

Link to article (subscription required).

Firm Highlights

Publication

How Antitrust and Unfair Competition Laws Affect Platform Providers’ Relationships With ISVs, API Developers, and Scrapers

A wide variety of business and consumer platforms host mutually beneficial ecosystems. But these ecosystems are also fraught with antitrust risk that arises when platforms try to terminate or modify the terms of third-party...

Read More
News

Daily Journal Names Farella Lawyers Among Top IP Lawyers in California

Farella Braun + Martel is proud to announce that partners Jeffrey M. Fisher and James L. Day were named to the 2020 list of “Top Intellectual Property Lawyers” in California by the Daily Journal...

Read More
News

Farella Represents Adobe Inc. in Prevailing on Petition to Transfer Patent Case Out of Western District of Texas

SAN FRANCISCO, July 29, 2020: Farella Braun + Martel announces that the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals has granted its client Adobe Inc.’s writ of mandamus petition seeking to transfer a patent case from...

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Attorneys Named 2020 IP Stars by Managing Intellectual Property - Firm Recommended for Patent Litigation

Farella Braun + Martel’s James L. Day , Jeffrey M. Fisher , Eugene Mar , Stephanie P. Skaff and Roderick M. Thompson have been named IP Stars by Managing Intellectual Property in its 2020...

Read More
News

Winston Liaw Selected as 2020 Leadership Council on Legal Diversity Pathfinder

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Attorneys, Practices Recognized by Chambers USA 2020

SAN FRANCISCO, April 23, 2020: Farella Braun + Martel announces that Chambers USA has recognized 12 lawyers and five practice areas in the legal directory’s 2020 edition. Individual Rankings: Tyler Gerking – Insurance: Policyholders...

Read More
Publication

Monetizing University Patent Portfolios During the Economic Downturn

Colleges and universities may be leaving money on the table with under-utilized patent portfolios. The time is right, as the law has shifted in favor of patent owners, both in inter partes review litigation...

Read More
Publication

Breaking up the Patent Monopoly for the Benefit of Batteries

The patent monopoly is at odds with the global need for battery storage technology. As the world mobilizes towards climate change solutions, companies with battery patents will face increasing pressure to share this critical...

Read More
Publication

Artificial Intelligence Can’t Patent Inventions: So What?

The USPTO’s  recent landmark decision  ( 16/524,350 ) concluding artificial intelligence (AI) cannot be a named patent inventor perhaps sparked fears of super-robots inventing critical technologies that, alas, receive no patent protection. If an...

Read More
Publication

Tech Companies Should Strongly Consider Monetizing Their Patent Portfolios During the Economic Downturn

The COVID-19 pandemic and widespread shelter-in-place orders have hit every corner of the country’s economy, including tech companies of all sizes. Many tech companies have traditionally maintained large patent portfolios to enhance company value...

Read More