Insights
Firm News

Section 230's Broad Liability Shield Seen as Living on Borrowed Time

October 13, 2022 Media Coverage
Communications Litigation Today

Erik Olson spoke to Communications Litigation Today for the article, "Section 230's Broad Liability Shield Seen as Living on Borrowed Time," discussing the implications of the coming SCOTUS decision in Gonzalez

In the article, Erik said SCOTUS justices opting to take up the case either "want to make a mark on the wall" or saw circuit courts leaving platforms too broad a shield. The Gonzalez petition details platforms' recommendation-centric revenue model -- keep users online longer by algorithms offering content they seemingly would like, based on past content consumption habits.

SCOTUS deciding recommendations fall outside the liability shield would mean platforms eliminating recommendations or changing their algorithms and adding human reviewers, Erik said. The former option seems unlikely, and the latter would increase platforms' costs but not eliminate their risk, he said. Section 230's power is in providing immunity that can be invoked early on, such as in a motion to dismiss, he said. If recommendations in some cases fall outside that immunity, litigation expenses will grow notably, he said.

Link to full article (subscription required).

Firm Highlights

Publication

SB 54: Shifting the Burden to Producers To Address California's Plastic Pollution

California's SB 54: Plastics Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act  (Public Resources Code § 41821.5) adopts the “extended producer responsibility model” (or “circular economy framework”), which makes manufacturers of single-use plastic products and packaging responsible...

Read More
News

Farella Names Carolina de Armas and Hilary Krase As Leadership Council on Legal Diversity Pathfinders

Carolina de Armas and Hilary Krase
Read More
Publication

Uncorking Accessibility: How Winery Websites Can Meet ADA Compliance Standards

Vanessa Ing and Kelsey Mollura discuss "Uncorking Accessibility: How Winery Websites Can Meet ADA Compliance Standards." The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a federal civil rights law that prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities...

Read More
Publication

One Pending Supreme Court Case Could Change the Internet as We Know It: Gonzalez v. Google and Tech Platforms’ Liability

The Supreme Court granted certiorari in Gonzalez v. Google , a high-stakes case appealed from the Ninth Circuit about the scope of protection Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act affords technology companies against...

Read More
News

Sarah Good Appointed to California State Bar Board of Trustees

Read More
News

Tony Schoenberg Receives Award of Merit From Bar Association of San Francisco

Anthony P. Schoenberg headshot
Read More
News

Judges Are Trying to Squeeze in More Trial Dates to Clear Court Backlogs

Farella partner and trial lawyer Karen Kimmey spoke to The Recorder  for the article, "Judges Are Trying to Squeeze in More Trial Dates to Clear Court Backlogs," discussing how lawyers are changing how they prepare for trial...

Read More
Publication

What Recent Rulings in 'hiQ v. LinkedIn' and Other Cases Say About the Legality of Data Scraping

LinkedIn obtained a permanent injunction on Dec. 6 in its six-year-old lawsuit against data scraping company hiQ Labs, which LinkedIn quickly cheered as a “final, decisive victory” that established an “important legal precedent.” While...

Read More