Insights
Publications

Employers May Require Exempt Employees to Use Accrued Leave for Absences Shorter Than Half a Day

7/24/2014 Articles

On July 21, 2014, a California Court of Appeal held that overtime exempt status is not undermined by requiring employees to use accrued leave for absences of less than half a day. 

In Rhea v. General Atomics, the employer required exempt employees to use accrued leave for any partial day absences, regardless of length.  Plaintiff Lori Rhea argued the practice defeated the California and federal law requirement that exempt employees receive a guaranteed salary without deductions for most partial day absences, known as the “salary basis test.” 

One prior California Court of Appeal opinion, however, had approved of employer policies allowing for the deduction of accrued leave from exempt employees for partial day absences, reasoning that reducing a leave-time bank is not the same as reducing cash salary.  Yet, some employers and commentators had assumed that authorization was limited to absences of at least half a day, and that deducting smaller increments would undermine the assumption that exempt employees’ hours are not closely tracked.

In Rhea, affirming summary judgment for General Atomics, the Court of Appeal held that the policy did not constitute a compensation reduction under the salary basis test because it did not take away or reclaim accrued paid leave.  The policy merely required that employees use the paid leave they have accrued for such absences.  The Court noted that employers are not required to provide paid leave and may set terms and conditions for the use of any paid leave time that is given.  Similarly, the Court rejected Rhea’s arguments that the policy at issue was an improper collection or withholding of wages, a secret payment of a lower wage, or a shifting of wages from one pay period to another.

Because this decision departs somewhat from earlier practices, employers would be best served to delay any changes in their PTO policies until at least August 30, 2014, the last day that the parties may appeal the decision to the California Supreme Court.  If the decision is left in place, employers will have greater flexibility in requiring the use of incremental paid leave for partial day absences.  However, there are a number of factors to consider before changing PTO plans, including the equities involved in requiring exempt employees to use paid leave for absences of a few hours, but not increasing compensation when those employees work late hours or weekends.  Likewise, even if an employee has used all available paid leave, the employee would still be entitled to take many health-related absences, and would do so without any reduction in base pay for partial day absences.  This may provide employees with an incentive to exhaust all accrued vacation or may inadvertently result in the perception that employees who have not used all their accrued time are at a disadvantage.  Thus, any cost-saving considerations must be weighed against the resulting effects on employee morale and the administrative burden of closely monitoring exempt employees’ daily work time.

Firm Highlights

Publication

How to Navigate California Wage Statement Penalties After Naranjo v. Spectrum

On May 6, 2024, the California Supreme Court, in Naranjo v. Spectrum Security Services Inc. , clarified that an employer is not liable for statutory penalties for inaccurate wage statements when it had a...

Read More
Publication

Important Changes and the Impact of California Industry-Specific Minimum Wage Laws

In the ever-evolving landscape of California labor laws, the minimum wage has once again taken center stage. With the recent state-wide increase to $16 per hour, the Golden State continues to lead the nation...

Read More
Publication

The Components of Effective and Defensible Workplace Investigations

Harassment, discrimination and retaliation are serious workplace threats that demand vigilant attention from employers under state and federal laws. This article explores some high-level yet essential components of effective workplace investigations. By understanding the...

Read More
Publication

Employment Law Update for Nonprofits With Holly Sutton

Welcome to  EO Radio Show - Your Nonprofit Legal Resource . Charities, foundations, and their founders often request help addressing employment practices and compliance questions. In this episode, host Cynthia Rowland is joined by Holly...

Read More
News

Ex-DraftKings Exec Seeks Fast Trial To Test Noncompete Law

Holly Sutton, chair of Farella's Employment Law Group, provided expert commentary to Law360 for the article "Ex-DraftKings Exec Seeks Fast Trial To Test Noncompete Law." Read the article here (subscription required).

Read More
Publication

A New Overtime Threshold Takes Effect in Mere Weeks: HR Should Assess Its Impact Now

On April 23, 2024, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) issued its final rule increasing the minimum pay requirements under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) for various exempt “white-collar” employee categories beginning on...

Read More
Publication

California’s Estrada Decision and Impact on Employers and PAGA Claims

Following Estrada v. Royalty Carpet Mills, Inc. , the California Supreme Court’s employee-friendly Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) ruling earlier this year, employers must remain more diligent than ever to prevent and mitigate costly...

Read More
Publication

Navigating California Wage Statement Penalties After Naranjo v. Spectrum Security Services, Inc.

On May 6, 2024, the California Supreme Court, in Naranjo v. Spectrum Security Services, Inc. , clarified that an employer is not liable for statutory penalties for inaccurate wage statements when it had a...

Read More
Publication

Navigating California's Evolving Legal Landscape Governing Leaves of Absence

California’s employment laws are no stranger to change, and recent years have witnessed the introduction or modification of various protected leaves by employees. In this article, we will delve into three significant leave categories...

Read More
Publication

Navigating Cannabis in the Workplace: A Guide for California Corporations

The landscape surrounding cannabis in the workplace is rapidly evolving, posing challenges for California corporations and businesses to establish effective policies and procedures. As the use of cannabis, both medical and recreational, becomes more...

Read More