Insights
Publications

Revenge of the Whistle-blower: Possible Consequences of Compliance Failures

2/14/2017 Articles

In a company with a robust compliance culture, potential whistleblowers can express their concerns without fear of retribution. By contrast, the penalty for a culture that silences whistleblowers just got steeper. Companies caught punishing those who raise red flags, especially when they turn out to be lawyers, could be forced to confront documents otherwise inadmissible against the company due to attorney-client privilege.

Sanford Wadler was once the General Counsel for the Northern California-based pharmaceutical company Bio-Rad. In February 2013, Wadler reported possible Foreign Corrupt Practices Act violations to the company’s audit committee. The report triggered an internal investigation, a $55 million dollar settlement with the DOJ and SEC, and, as a federal jury held yesterday, resulted in Wadler’s wrongful termination.

Wadler was terminated in June 2013—allegedly for performance problems—after 25 years with the company. He brought suit in 2015 alleging illegal whistleblower retaliation. To make his case Wadler sought to introduce company documents from the FCPA internal investigation and other records gleaned from his years at the companyBio-Rad responded that “virtually every document in the case” could be protected by the attorney-client privilege and any use of that material would violate state ethics rules. Notably, the SEC weighed in, arguing that federal securities law supersedes state ethics rules and federal common law related to privilege.

Magistrate Judge Spero agreed with Wadler and the SEC, finding that, “privileged communication and confidential information may be used, with appropriate protections, to establish whistleblower retaliation claims under the federal common law.” As a result, Wadler was able to use sealing orders to introduce privileged material against his former employer, resulting in an almost $8 million victory.

As a result of this verdict, corporate counsel with compliance concerns now have stronger protections if they are punished for escalating their concerns. To protect the corporate privilege and strengthen compliance norms, corporations must ensure mechanisms for adequately responding to and protecting whistleblowers, whether in-house lawyers or otherwise.

Firm Highlights

Publication

Internal Investigations for Nonprofits: A Means of Identifying and Addressing Misconduct Before the Regulators Come Calling

The worst nightmare for most nonprofit board members is a complaint that sparks an investigation of misconduct at the organization. The ember may have been burning for some time before the board becomes aware...

Read More
News

Companies Increasingly Investigating Their Own Cultures—Even When There Are No Complaints

Aviva Gilbert, Farella partner and co-chair of the firm's White Collar Criminal Defense and Internal Corporate Investigations practice, spoke to Corporate Counsel for the article "Companies Increasingly Investigating Their Own Cultures—Even When There Are...

Read More
News

Will Other States Follow in California's Footsteps Regarding Cryptocurrency Regulation?

Aviva Gilbert, partner and co-chair of Farella's White Collar Criminal Defense and Internal Corporate Investigations Group, was quoted in the Daily Business Review article, "Will Other States Follow in California's Footsteps Regarding Cryptocurrency Regulation?" In...

Read More
News

50 Farella Lawyers in 2023 The Best Lawyers in America® and the Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America™; 4 Lawyer of the Year Awards

Read More
News

Farella Attorneys Named to 2022 Northern California Super Lawyers and Rising Stars

Thirty-four Farella Braun + Martel lawyers were named to the Super Lawyers and Rising Stars lists of top attorneys in Northern California for 2022. Super Lawyers: Carly Alameda – Business Litigation George Argyris &ndash...

Read More
News

Chambers USA 2022 Recognizes Farella Braun + Martel Lawyers, Practices

Farella Braun + Martel is pleased to announce that Chambers USA has recognized 14 lawyers and 6 practice areas in the legal directory’s 2022 edition. Individual California and Western U.S. Rankings: Sarah Bell &ndash...

Read More
News

As Feds Step Up White-Collar Enforcement, Companies Face Heightened Risks

Aviva Gilbert, Farella partner and co-chair of the firm's White Collar Criminal Defense and Internal Corporate Investigations Group, was quoted in the Corporate Counsel article "As Feds Step Up White-Collar Enforcement, Companies Face Heightened...

Read More
Publication

Investigations, Audits, Subpoenas, Oh My!

Our Nonprofit Education Series speakers Cynthia Rowland, Aviva Gilbert and guest speaker, Stephanie Fauerbach from FTI Consulting, discuss "Investigations, Audits, Subpoenas, Oh My!" Nonprofit entities can be just as prone to misconduct (theft, embezzlement, accounting snafus...

Read More
Publication

Internal Investigations for Nonprofits: A Means of Identifying and Addressing Misconduct Before the Regulators Come Calling

Cynthia Rowland: Welcome to EO Radio Show , Your Nonprofit Legal Resource, brought to you by the Exempt Organizations Group at Farella Braun + Martel. My name is Cynthia Roland and I'm a partner at Farella...

Read More
Publication

The Humility To Prepare and the Confidence To Pull It off With Doug Young

Mike Herring interviews past ACTL President Doug Young in this episode of  Trial Tested: A Podcast by the American College of Trial Lawyers . S3E6: The Humility To Prepare and the Confidence To Pull It off With...

Read More