Insights
Publications

Second Circuit Confirms HathiTrust Digital Library's Full-Text Search Constitutes Fair Use in Copyright Case

6/18/2014 Articles

Last week, the Second Circuit issued its decision in the closely watched Authors Guild, Inc. et al. v. HathiTrust et al. copyright infringement case.  At issue was whether the use of copyrighted material in the HathiTrust Digital Library (“HDL”)—a text-searchable digital collection of books created from hard copies provided by various universities and scanned by Google without permission of the copyright owners—is protected against the plaintiff-authors’ claims of copyright infringement under the doctrine of “fair use.”  Farella submitted an amicus brief in support of HathiTrust on behalf of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, Public Knowledge, and the Center for Democracy & Technology.

The Second Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision that the HDL’s use of the copyrighted works for full-text search constitutes a “fair use.”  The Court first determined that the HDL’s creation of a full-text searchable database from hard copy books is a “quintessentially transformative use,” because “the result of a word search is different in purpose, character, expression, meaning, and message from the page (and the book) from which it is drawn.”  Thus, the HDL “adds to the original something new with a different purpose and a different character.”  The Court noted that the HDL only displays the number of times a search term appears on a particular page of a book, and does not allow users to view any portion of the books they are searching.  The Court rejected the authors’ arguments that the use was not “fair” because every copy employed by the HDL in generating full-text searches represents a lost opportunity to license the book for search, reasoning that the “market harm” factor of the fair use analysis requires that the new use serve as a substitute for the original, and search is a new use that clearly does not. 

The Court also affirmed the district court’s ruling that fair use allows the libraries to provide the works in formats accessible to the print-disabled, but declined to address the issue of whether the HDL’s preservation of the books in digital format constitutes a fair use—citing lack of evidence, standing, and ripeness—and remanded the issue back to the district court.

The decision represents an important win for technology innovators, recognizing that full-text searching constitutes fair use and setting precedent that may pave the way for other new digital age uses of copyrighted works to be considered fair use.

Firm Highlights

Publication

Three Steps Licensees Can Take to Protect Their IP Rights in Bankruptcy

During periods of widespread economic disruption such as the present, operating businesses must be able to identify and respond to threats to the financial health of their contracting counterparts in order to protect key...

Read More
Publication

Insights Into the First Patent Trial in Waco, Texas - MV3 Partners v. Roku

A 7-person jury in Waco, Texas, recently returned its verdict in the first patent trial held before Judge Albright: defense verdict, no finding of infringement. In the MV3 Partners v. Roku dispute, MV3 Partners...

Read More
News

Farella Braun Files Amicus Brief in Support of Humanitarian Organizations in Ninth Circuit Appeal of WhatsApp v. NSO

SAN FRANCISCO, December 23, 2020: Northern California legal powerhouse Farella Braun + Martel today submitted an amicus brief in support of civil society organizations in the NSO Group v. WhatsApp appeal pending before the...

Read More
News

3 Things To Know After Busy WDTX Patent Judge's 1st Trial

Eugene Mar spoke to Law360 about the  MV3 Partners LLC v. Roku Inc.  case in the article, " 3 Things To Know After Busy WDTX Patent Judge's 1st Trial." In the article, Eugene said he's...

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Elevates Five to Partner

Read More
Publication

Breaking up the Patent Monopoly for the Benefit of Batteries

The patent monopoly is at odds with the global need for battery storage technology. As the world mobilizes towards climate change solutions, companies with battery patents will face increasing pressure to share this critical...

Read More
Publication

How Antitrust and Unfair Competition Laws Affect Platform Providers’ Relationships With ISVs, API Developers, and Scrapers

A wide variety of business and consumer platforms host mutually beneficial ecosystems. But these ecosystems are also fraught with antitrust risk that arises when platforms try to terminate or modify the terms of third-party...

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Ranked Among “Best Law Firms” by U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers

SAN FRANCISCO, November 5, 2020: Farella Braun + Martel earned national and regional rankings across a number of practice areas in the U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers® release of the “Best...

Read More
Publication

Artificial Intelligence Can’t Patent Inventions: So What?

The USPTO’s  recent landmark decision  ( 16/524,350 ) concluding artificial intelligence (AI) cannot be a named patent inventor perhaps sparked fears of super-robots inventing critical technologies that, alas, receive no patent protection. If an...

Read More
Event

Cannabis IP: Using Intellectual Property to Protect Your Assets and Grow Your Business

Join Nate Garhart and Ashley Roybal-Reid in the discussion on "Cannabis IP: Using Intellectual Property to Protect Your Assets and Grow Your Business." Intellectual property (IP) is a critical issue in the cannabis industry...

Read More