Insights
Publications

Will It Go Forward? First Cannabis Patent Infringement Case Filed in Federal Court

8/9/2018 Articles

A patent infringement case pending in front of the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado has the potential to set an important precedent that will have ramifications for many of our clients in this space.  In United Cannabis Corporation v. Pure Hemp Collective, Inc., United Cannabis alleges that Pure Hemp has infringed its patent related to a liquid formulation of plant cannabinoid extracts.   

This is a fascinating case that brings an issued cannabis patent into federal court in the context of a dispute over activity that is legal under state law but illegal, and politically sensitive, under federal law.  It is unclear whether the court will allow a cannabis patent infringement case to go forward, particularly where it seeks money damages for the accused infringer’s sale of cannabis.  As the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has noted, “the principle that inventions are invalid if they are principally designed to serve immoral or illegal purposes has not been applied broadly in recent years.”  Juicy Whip, Inc. v. Orange Bang, Inc., 185 F. 3d 1364, 1366-67 (Fed. Cir. 1999).

If the case does go forward, the plaintiff will likely need to produce potentially incriminating evidence directly under the supervision of the federal court, including evidence of its own cannabis operations and sales to substantiate its case. 

If the court dismisses the case or otherwise balks at enforcing a cannabis patent, the case could be ripe for a politically charged appeal.  The plaintiff could claim that its federally-granted property right was vitiated without due process. 

We are watching the developments of this case carefully. The result could provide guidance to entrepreneurs considering applying for patents on cannabis-related inventions, or enforcing such patents in court.

Firm Highlights

News

Prior Litigation Can Impact Coverage in Future Disputes

GlobeSt.com March 6, 2019 "Prior Litigation Can Impact Coverage in Future Disputes" Insurance Recovery Senior Associate Shanti Eagle discusses how positions taken by insureds in prior litigation can impact or foreclose coverage in subsequent disputes...

Read More
Publication

Doing Business With the Cannabis Industry? Make Sure Your Insurance Will Cover You

By Shanti Eagle, Farella Braun + Martel, and Martin Fox-Foster, Emergent Risk Insurance Services Much has been written about the difficulties and limitations of insuring leaf-touching cannabis businesses. However, any individual or company simply interacting...

Read More
Publication

Evicting Tenants Over “Illegal” Cannabis Operation Comes Back to Bite Landlords in Coverage

A 6th Circuit case decided earlier this year demonstrates how positions taken by insureds in prior litigation can impact or foreclose coverage in subsequent disputes with insurers. See K.V.G. Properties, Inc. v. Westfield Ins....

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Advises Cannabis Distributor Blackbird Holdings Corp. in Sale to TILT Holdings Inc. for $50 Million

SAN FRANCISCO (January 29, 2019): Farella Braun + Martel represented Blackbird Holdings Corp. , a distribution company providing operations and software solutions that facilitate the movement of cannabis products at each touchpoint within the...

Read More
Event

North Coast Cannabis Industry Conference

Farella Braun + Martel is proud to underwrite the North Coast Cannabis Industry Conference featuring keynote speaker Aaron Smith, co-founder and executive director of the National Cannabis Industry Association. The event will also feature...

Read More
Publication

Who 'Owns' a Secret? Whether Trade Secret Licensees Have Standing to Sue in California

If the eye-popping damages awards in several recent lawsuits are any indication, companies are increasingly coming to see their private information as one of their most valuable assets—and California juries apparently agree. For example,...

Read More
Publication

Insuring Cannabis: Not Business As Usual, Yet

The legalization of cannabis in many states is helping the industry to become mainstream and gain access to insurance products taken for granted in other economic sectors.   But there is still a long...

Read More
Event

Insurance for the Cannabis Industry

Shanti Eagle is the moderator of this BASF Insurance Section program co-sponsored with the Cannabis Section. This panel will provide important risk management and insurance placement advice to those dealing with businesses involved in cannabis...

Read More
Publication

CBD in Foods and Beverages? Not Quite Yet

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Wins Benchmark Litigation 2019 San Francisco Firm of the Year Award

SAN FRANCISCO, March 15, 2019: Farella Braun + Martel announces it has been named “San Francisco Firm of the Year” by Benchmark Litigation . Farella Partner Douglas Young accepted the award on behalf of...

Read More