Publications

California’s New Voidable Transactions Act

9/8/2015 Articles

California’s recently enacted  Uniform Voidable Transactions Act (UVTA), makes it easier for creditors to recover assets that are transferred to third parties when a debtor is insolvent, even when there is no improper intent by the debtor or the transferee. 

The UVTA supersedes the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (California Civil Code Sections 3439 et seq.) (UFTA). The UVTA applies to transfers made or obligations incurred after January 1, 2016 (the UFTA will continue to apply to prior transactions). Key changes from the UFTA include:

  • Challenging a transfer will be easier for a creditor: the creditor only needs to establish its claim by a “preponderance” of the evidence, rather than the higher “clear and convincing” evidence standard applied by some courts under the UFTA. Moreover, a party defending a claim now clearly has the burden of: (i) rebutting the presumption that the debtor was insolvent at the time of the transfer based on failure to pay debts as they came due and (ii) asserting that property was transferred for a reasonably equivalent value and in good faith. These procedural changes may sound technical, but they tilt the scales in favor of the creditor.
  • A creditor asserting a UVTA claim now has additional remedies, including obtaining pre-judgment “attachment” of a transferee’s assets generally, rather than such attachment being limited to the asset transferred or its proceeds, as is the case under the UFTA. This will put additional pressure on a transferee to settle.

The name change itself (from Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act to Uniform Voidable Transactions Act) emphasizes that the law is focused on avoidance of transfers made or of obligations incurred by an insolvent debtor in exchange for less than reasonably equivalent value, regardless of actual fraud or improper intent. 

A claim under the UVTA is now governed by the law of the state where the debtor is “located” at the time the transfer is made or the obligation is incurred. For an individual, this is the individual's principal residence; for an organization, this is the organization's place of business, or its chief executive office if it has multiple places of business. This change is designed to reduce uncertainty regarding the law applicable to a claim, which can be critical because states have adopted non-uniform versions of the UFTA and UVTA. Defendants have often used uncertainty regarding which version of the UFTA to apply as a tool to hinder creditor claims.

Navigating a claim under UFTA and the new UVTA can be tricky, the more so now as the law evolves to focus on technical rules that might not appear obviously. The advice of legal counsel with appropriate experience will be critical to pursuing or defending such litigation.

Firm Highlights

Publication

How Grape Growers Can Protect Their Interests When a Winery Approaches Insolvency

A lot goes into the making of great wine, and when a winery becomes financially unstable, there are multiple competing interests that need to be satisfied, including the banks that provide the winery with...

Read More
Publication

Treatment of Commercial Leases in Tenant Bankruptcy - The Basics

As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to wreak havoc with the nation’s economy, we have started to see bankruptcy filings by well-known companies such as GNC, J. Crew, Neiman Marcus, Modell’s, 24 Hour Fitness, Gold’s...

Read More
Publication

Hospitality Companies and Their Lenders: Preparing for Difficult Conversations

In a sudden reversal of generally expansionary trends, the hospitality business has been among the most immediate and badly hit economic sectors as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the resulting stay-at-home and...

Read More
Publication

Wine Businesses, Lenders, and Difficult Conversations

The COVID-19 pandemic and public health efforts to combat it will impact different wine businesses in different ways. Those that depend on on-premise and direct-to-consumer (DTC) sales, such as restaurant, hospitality, and tasting room...

Read More
Publication

Questions Wineries Need to Answer Before Talking With Lenders About Coronavirus-Caused Financial Woes

The coronavirus pandemic and public health efforts to combat it will impact different wine businesses in different ways. Those that depend upon on-premise and direct-to-consumer (DTC) sales — such as restaurant, hospitality, and tasting room...

Read More
Publication

Protecting Suppliers and Customers of Insolvent or Bankrupt Companies

Some 3,600 companies having already  filed for Chapter 11 protection  in the first half of 2020—more than in any year since 2012—and many are bracing for an even greater surge of bankruptcy filings before...

Read More
Publication

Non-Residential Lease Default Workouts, Security Deposits and Bankruptcy

What are the bankruptcy implications of the treatment of a tenant’s security deposit following a payment default?  Many non-residential tenants are now or are likely in the future to be unable to pay rent...

Read More
Publication

Three Steps Licensees Can Take to Protect Their IP Rights in Bankruptcy

During periods of widespread economic disruption such as the present, operating businesses must be able to identify and respond to threats to the financial health of their contracting counterparts in order to protect key...

Read More