Firm News

Law360 Rainmaker Q&A: Farella Braun's Mary McCutcheon

September 29, 2016 Media Coverage

Mary E. McCutcheon is an insurance recovery partner in Farella Braun & Martel's San Francisco office and is chairwoman of Farella's construction and insurance department. Over the past 30 years, she has represented corporations, public entities and individuals in a variety of insurance coverage disputes, ranging from tech sector meltdowns to options backdating claims to earthquake losses.

She advises companies and individual directors regarding issues involved in the placement of directors' and officers' liability insurance and related indemnification issues, as well as handling claims that arise under those policies.

McCutcheon is a founding member of the American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel and serves as its secretary/treasurer and also on its Executive Committee. She is a member and past president of the board of directors of the National Center for Youth Law. McCutcheon is recognized among the leading insurance attorneys in California by Chambers USA and Best Lawyers in America.

Q: What skill was most important for you in becoming a rainmaker?

A: Learning to listen to what the client was looking for in an attorney and convey to them how my skills and experience would help them solve their problems.

Q: How do you prepare a pitch for a potential new client?

A: Besides the standard preparation of learning about the prospective client, its industry and the parties involved, I also think about how the coverage dispute fits into the underlying litigation, and what the client’s goals are. If there is not yet a dispute, but the client is worried that one might arise in the future, how do I work with the client, broker and defense counsel to minimize the likelihood of that future dispute?

If there is an actual dispute, are we trying to settle the underlying case with insurance money and work out the coverage issues later, or trying to settle both at the same time? Or does the client want to litigate the case, but make sure the insurance company will pay the defense fees and judgment if the case doesn’t go as well as defense counsel predicted?

If the client has settled the case with its own money, what leverage can we create to advance an acceptable settle of its claim against the insurer? Or is it time to draft and file the bad faith complaint? Different clients will have different opinions on how to proceed in coverage disputes, based on business considerations as well as their assessment of the litigation and coverage risks. During the pitch (which is often just a call from defense counsel), I need to be able not only to quickly identify and analyze the coverage issues, but also explore what strategies might work best based upon what is happening in the underlying case and what the client wants to achieve.

Q: Share an example of a time when landing a client was especially difficult, and how you handled it.

A: The prospective client called and asked if I had ever handled a specific type of coverage case. The insurance case arose out of a liability case in an emerging area of litigation relating to the 2008 financial crisis, and the coverage disputes were only just beginning to gel. Not only were there few active claims, but there was no case law on the coverage issues arising from this emerging area. So I had not yet handled that specific type of coverage case, much less developed a track record in successfully resolving such cases.

I was honest, but also was able to learn enough about the coverage dispute in the course of the conversation to demonstrate to the client that this case involved insurance policies and legal issues which were very similar to those involved in litigation stemming from a previous financial crisis, in which I had significant coverage experience. I got the engagement.

Q: What should aspiring rainmakers focus on when beginning their law careers?

A: I have lots of advice!

1. Call me “Captain Obvious,” but do your best work. You never know who will see you in action and later need your services.

2. Treat everyone you encounter in your career with respect. You can (most of the time) represent your clients aggressively and effectively without alienating opposing counsel. You can disagree with actions taken by brokers or defense counsel without calling them out or making them look bad to the client. Opposing counsel, defense counsel and brokers can become future referral sources.

3. You can’t be all things to all people. Don’t be afraid to take on new challenges or new areas of specialty within your field, but also don’t be afraid to pull in other attorneys from your firm if you think they have better expertise in the subject area or would be a better fit for the client

Q: What’s the most challenging aspect of remaining a rainmaker?

A: You can’t rest on your laurels. You have to continuously demonstrate your value to clients and referral sources, and keep developing new ones.

Firm Highlights


Maximizing Business Insurance Coverage Benefits After a Fire

Unfortunately, we again write while wildfire is devouring homes and businesses in Napa and Sonoma, and threatening many more. We’ve previously posted tips about first steps that you should take in the event your...

Read More

Amy Briggs Inducted to American College of Coverage Counsel

Read More

Lawyers Advising California’s Wineries Navigate a Pandemic and Wildfires

Partners Tyler Gerking and Matt Lewis were interviewed in the Daily Journal article "Lawyers advising California’s wineries navigate a pandemic and wildfires."

Read More

Insurance Dispute Resolution

Farella's Real Estate Webinar Series features Amy Briggs discussing "Insurance Dispute Resolution." Businesses have filed claims seeking recovery help under their insurance policies due to various governmental closure orders arising from the COVID-19 pandemic. Losses related...

Read More

What Nonprofits Need to Know About Landlord-Tenants Relationships and Insurance

Amy Briggs and Tony Schoenberg discuss "What Nonprofits Need to Know About Landlord-Tenants Relationships and Insurance." Real estate is one of the most significant costs for an exempt organization. Furthermore, the laws governing landlord-tenant...

Read More

D&O Professionals Series: Tyler Gerking Discusses D&O Coverage and Litigation

Insurance Recovery partner Tyler Gerking explores current trends and observations on D&O coverage and litigation on Willis Towers Watson's "D&O Professionals Series." Read the full article,  here .

Read More

Maximizing Insurance Coverage: What Cannabis Businesses Need to Know

Farella's Cannabis Industry Education Series features Tyler Gerking discussing "Maximizing Insurance Coverage: What Cannabis Businesses Need to Know." The cannabis industry has flourished, along with it the cannabis insurance market has grown. As more carriers...

Read More

“Unfair Trade Practices” Exclusion Does Not Extend to Consumer Protection Claims

Two phrases combined in a single exclusion—“alleging, arising out of, based upon or attributable to any violation of any law…” and “as respects… unfair trade practices” could inspire carriers to make trouble for policyholders...

Read More