Insights
Publications

A Wake-Up Call For Cities And Counties To Meet Regional Housing Needs

3/24/2010 Articles

In a widely anticipated decision, an Alameda County Superior Court judge ordered the City of Pleasanton to eliminate its voter-mandated housing limit in order to satisfy the state requirement that all cities and counties zone land sufficient to enable construction of its share of housing affordable to a variety of household incomes.  (Urban Habitat Program and State of California v. City of Pleasanton, Case No. RG06-293831, March 12, 2010).  The Urban Habitat Program, an Oakland-based non-profit formed to advance environmental, economic, and social justice in the Bay Area, joined by Attorney General Jerry Brown, sued Pleasanton for its failure to satisfy its Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA). 

The RHNA is a method of ensuring that each local government uses its land use regulations to facilitate construction of its fair share of regional housing  needs, including housing affordable to a wide variety of households.  In the Bay Area, the determination of each jurisdiction's RHNA is made by the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG).  Typically, a jurisdiction adopts its ABAG-RHNA requirement as part of the Housing Element of its General Plan, and implements that requirement through its zoning regulations. 

In Pleasanton, however, the voters had imposed a permanent cap of 29,000 units, 27,000 of which already exist, leaving an inventory of only 2,000 new units.  The result of that cap, according to the judge, was that Pleasanton would never be unable to comply with its RHNA because the cap limits the number of units that can be built to a number significantly below Pleasanton's RHNA.  In other words, the RHNA will always exceed the cap.

Pleasanton is not the only local jurisdiction in California that has a cap on the total number of units or other stringent growth control measures aimed at new residential construction.  Until now, these restrictions have gone unnoticed.  However, this case puts those California cities and counties on notice that the Office of the Attorney General is willing to use its considerable legal muscle to invalidate those restrictions and compel these jurisdictions to make way for housing affordable to a wide variety of households. 

Firm Highlights

Publication

Office-to-Housing Conversion: Legislation – California’s Next Frontier

In an effort to spur the conversion of office-to-housing as one way to revitalize California’s struggling urban downtown areas, Assemblyman (and former San Francisco Supervisor) Matt Haney has introduced AB 1532, dubbed the “Office...

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Announces 2023 New Partner Class

Read More
News

Ashley Breakfield Elected 2023 President-Elect of CREW SF

Ashely Breakfield Headshot
Read More
Publication

San Francisco’s Downtown: What Does the Future Hold?

Farella's CJ Higley with guest speakers, Marc Babsin with Emerald Fund, Jim Hakes with Handel Architects, Sujata Srivastava with SPUR, and Anne Taupier with San Francisco Office of Economic and Workforce Development, discuss "San...

Read More
News

Lawdragon Names 7 Farella Partners Among “Leaders in Environmental Law”

Northern California legal powerhouse Farella Braun + Martel is pleased to announce that seven partners were selected to the 2023 Lawdragon Green 500: Leaders in Environmental Law Guide. Selected for inclusion are: Sarah Bell &ndash...

Read More
Publication

Controversial New Law Opens Door To More Residential Development In California

It has been praised as a long-overdue step to address California’s chronic housing shortage, while others have called it the “worst bill of the year.” But regardless of public opinion, the Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs...

Read More
News

Planning Commission OKs Bella Union Winery at Former Provenance Facility in Rutherford

Katherine Philippakis was quoted in the Wine Business article, "Planning Commission OKs Bella Union Winery at Former Provenance Facility in Rutherford."  The goal for the “foreseeable future” is for Bella Union to produce 110,000...

Read More
Publication

A Year in Review: SB 9 Slow to Gain Traction

A year since the approval of Senate Bill 9 (SB 9), it appears few Californians have taken advantage of the new legislation that aims to streamline small-scale housing development. The bill allows for the...

Read More
Publication

State Minimum Fire Safe Regulations Go Into Effect April 1, 2023

The State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection has been actively pursuing comprehensive new wildfire protection standards for development in Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones and State Responsibility Areas where the State of...

Read More
Publication

How New Climate Change CEQA Thresholds Will Impact Bay Area Development Projects

Farella's CJ Higley and Donald Sobelman with guest speakers, Michael Keinath from Ramboll and Tania Sheyner from City and County of San Francisco, discuss "How New Climate Change CEQA Thresholds Will Impact Bay Area Development...

Read More