Build a Gift Acceptance Policy Before Saying Yes to Your Next Big Gift
Not every gift should be accepted. Some contributions cost more in administrative burden, legal risk, or reputational exposure than they deliver in mission-advancing value. A well-crafted gift acceptance policy equips your organization to recognize the difference and to say “No, thank you” when prudence demands it.
A gift acceptance policy defines the kinds of gifts a charity accepts and outlines the process for evaluating prospective contributions. The policy should be seen as a strategic enabler, not simply a compliance document. Organizations that develop the capacity to handle complex gifts, like marketable securities, can grow their contributions substantially faster than those that only accept gifts of cash.
The benefits of a well-designed policy include:
- Reducing the risks of ad hoc decision-making by establishing the framework for deciding whether, and on what terms, to accept a gift.
- Educating staff and board members about the reputational risks and legal liabilities of mishandling gift opportunities.
- Signaling to donors that the organization follows best practices.
- Providing credibility with auditors, state regulators, and the IRS.
Nonprofit Gift Acceptance Policy Guidelines
Your gift acceptance policy should be anchored by key principles aimed at protecting both the donor and the organization:
- Never encourage a gift that exceeds the donor’s means.
- Staff must avoid providing legal or tax advice and should recommend the donor obtain their own independent counsel.
- When the donor is a board member, especially one proposing a complex gift, the gift acceptance policy should track with the organization’s conflict of interest policy, requiring disclosure and recusal from the acceptance decision.
- Gift amounts and donor identity should be kept confidential and not publicly recognized without the donor’s written consent.
- The organization’s legal counsel should create or review binding planned gift agreements, and donors should be advised to retain their own.
- Every non-cash asset should have a viable exit strategy. A gift with no realistic path to conversion is more of a liability than an asset.
A tiered approach to decision-making generally balances flexibility and risk management. Executive staff can typically approve low-risk, high-liquidity gifts like cash, publicly traded securities, and unrestricted, irrevocable bequests. Approval by the board or a standing gift acceptance committee is the best practice for complex or high-risk gifts, such as real property, closely held business interests, and tangible personal property.
Above all, the policy should state clearly that the organization reserves the right to decline any gift that is inconsistent with its mission, carries undue cost or liability, or poses reputational risk.
Evaluate Gifts by Asset Type
A gift acceptance policy should calibrate diligence to risk. Every asset type ultimately reduces to three questions: How liquid is the gift, what will it cost to convert or hold, and who approves the terms?
Cash is the simplest category. The main policy considerations are the assessment and approval procedures for any donor-imposed restrictions.
Publicly traded securities require a brokerage account and a standing instruction to liquidate on receipt. Be mindful of securities-law restrictions when the donor is an insider.
Closely held business interests (like private company stock or an LLC interest) require independent legal counsel, transfer-restriction review, and analysis of unrelated business taxable income risk. Many organizations elect to decline these categorically.
Tangible personal property (like art, vehicles, or jewelry) should generally only be accepted if the board confirms the property is marketable and its carrying costs are manageable.
Cryptocurrency and digital assets should usually be routed through a third-party custodian for prompt liquidation. Note that crypto assets are not treated as publicly traded securities for the donor’s deduction purposes.
Real estate, oil, gas, and mineral interests all require comprehensive diligence, including physical inspection, environmental review, title search, carrying-cost analysis, and careful evaluation of any assumed debt (which can trigger unrelated business taxable income).
Gift Compliance and Agreement Considerations
Accepting a gift triggers certain compliance obligations that the policy should explicitly address:
- A contemporaneous written acknowledgment is required for every gift of $250 or more. It should include the date, the amount (or a description of the property), and a statement regarding any goods or services provided in exchange, with a good-faith estimate of their value.
- The donor must report non-cash gifts over $500 on IRS Form 8283. For non-cash contributions exceeding $5,000, other than marketable securities, an authorized officer of the recipient organization must sign Form 8283 to acknowledge receipt, and the donor must obtain a qualified appraisal.
- If the organization disposes of donated property (other than marketable securities) within three years of receipt, it must file Form 8282 within 125 days.
- Schedule M of Form 990 is required when total non-cash contributions exceed $25,000 or include art, historical treasures, or qualified conservation contributions.
Donor naming rights also merit careful policy treatment. Agreements should confirm the organization’s right to remove recognition if a building is demolished or substantially renovated and should include a “morality” clause allowing removal of recognition if the donor’s reputation later conflicts with the organization’s mission.
Endowments should be clearly distinguished between board-designated funds and true endowments, which are donor-restricted under the Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act (UPMIFA) and generally cannot be released from their restrictions without donor consent or court approval. The gift agreement for an endowment should include a release mechanism, allowing the board to redirect funds if the restricted purpose ceases to exist or becomes impractical.
Put the Policy Into Practice
Tailor your gift acceptance policy to your organization’s actual needs; avoid using a template or AI-generated draft without appropriate customization. Periodically review your policy as laws, asset types, and organizational capacity evolve. Most importantly, apply it consistently, as a policy’s real value is measured by its use in practice.
If your organization does not yet have a formal gift acceptance policy, make creating one a near-term board priority. If you have one, confirm it has been reviewed recently, addresses the full spectrum of assets your donors may offer, and is actually being followed. A sound policy that is current and uniformly used will ensure you can accept gifts with the confidence that each one advances the mission it was intended to support.
Featured in NonProfit PRO here.
Cynthia Rowland is a partner and Allyson Deraps is special counsel in Farella Braun + Martel’s Exempt Organizations practice. Farella is a San Francisco-based law firm.
Subscribe to Farella Insights by topic and author here.
/Passle/65737bea961a63814fd9b845/MediaLibrary/Images/2025-07-21-23-30-54-976-687ecdae3c5c081e6e9e0d61.jpg)