Insights
Publications

Key PFAS Regulatory Standards Set in California

June 16, 2020 Articles
Industry Today

In support of California’s efforts to investigate and evaluate the presence of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in the environment, the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Board) has released interim final Environmental Screening Levels (ESLs) for two key prevalent PFAS compounds: perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) and perfluorooctanoate (PFOA). These ESLs provide critical guidance regarding what levels of contamination will require investigation and cleanup, across the state. In addition, these new standards will be influential across the country, as other states grapple with widespread detections of PFAS in groundwater and surface waters.

The Current Regulatory Landscape

PFAS compounds were manufactured in the United States beginning in the 1940s. Their ability to repel oil and water led to their widespread use in consumer products, such as non-stick pans, raincoats, carpets and upholstery, and food packaging. PFAS compounds were also widely used in industrial processes, including chrome plating, electronics manufacturing, and firefighting foams. Over the last decade, it has become clear that PFAS—which have been linked to a number of potential health effects—are present in groundwater and surface waters across the country that are used as sources of drinking water.

Federal law currently does not regulate PFAS. But the U.S. EPA has pledged to evaluate potential PFAS regulations, including designating certain compounds as “hazardous substances” under CERCLA (i.e., Superfund), setting maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) for drinking water, and developing regulatory standards at cleanup sites.

In the meantime, California has taken action. In 2019, the State Water Resources Control Board sent PFAS investigation orders to priority facilities across the state (including commercial airports, municipal solid waste landfills, and chrome plating facilities), as well as hundreds of public water systems that are near such facilities and/or have had PFAS detections.

The New ESLs for California Will Impact PFAS Standards Nationwide

To facilitate the state investigations, the Regional Board issued two memoranda on May 27—one setting forth interim final ESLs for PFOS and PFOA, and a second setting out a regulatory approach using those ESLs.

The new ESLs will become a key driver for assessing PFAS contamination across California. ESLs are risk-based concentrations of chemicals against which sampling data can be compared. Where ESLs are exceeded, the site may pose a significant threat to human health or the environment, and further investigation is warranted (and often required) to determine whether cleanup is necessary. ESLs therefore play an important role in many contexts, including due diligence for property acquisitions, use of a water source as drinking water (in the absence of MCLs), and regulatory investigations.

ESLs also serve as a bellwether for other states that are setting standards for the same chemicals. Given the absence of federal regulation of PFAS, the new ESLs will play a key role in decision making in many jurisdictions. Moreover, in states without PFAS screening levels or other standards, private parties assessing PFAS risk will look to the new ESLs as a significant factor in their analysis.

Regulatory Action Using the ESLs

The Regional Board will use the new ESLs as part of a regulatory approach to PFAS testing, investigation, and cleanup that will initially focus on priority sites, including:

  • Firefighting practice training areas;
  • Semiconductor facilities;
  • Electronics manufacturers;
  • Former chrome plating facilities and non-chrome metal plating and finishing facilities;
  • Mining industry (copper, gold, aluminum, vanadium, and uranium);
  • Textile manufacturers and processors;
  • Furniture manufacturers and upholsterers;
  • Carpet manufacturers;
  • Cardboard/paper packaging manufacturers;
  • Surface coatings/paints/varnish manufacturers and high-volume users; and
  • Manufacturers of known PFAS-containing products, such as dental floss, non-stick cookware, food packaging materials, waterproof textiles, medical garments, and personal care products.

Results of the testing will be compared with ESLs and used to decide whether to require additional site investigation and/or cleanup.

This approach is likely to be replicated across California and in other jurisdictions focused on PFAS contamination and related public health issues.

Analysis and Conclusions

The interim final ESLs are a major step forward into the uncharted, but fast approaching, world of routine PFAS site assessment and cleanup. For sites where PFAS sampling has already been conducted, these ESLs offer an opportunity to proactively review and evaluate regulatory risk, and to develop a response strategy. For those who have been hesitant to conduct testing due to the lack of screening levels, key guidance is now available.

Given that PFAS compounds have been detected in groundwater and surface water throughout California and the rest of the United States, efforts to investigate and clean up PFAS will rapidly intensify. As a result of the new ESLs, property owners (and potential purchasers of property) are now in a better position to take meaningful steps to understand the potential risks and costs associated with PFAS contamination.

Firm Highlights

Publication

The FASTER Act: What Companies Need To Know About the New Food Allergy Law

While the Food Allergy Safety, Treatment, Education, and Research Act (FASTER Act) only makes a minor change to add sesame as a major food allergen, it signals the government’s intent to closely examine food...

Read More
Publication

Continuing Use of CGL Policies to Cover Data Breach Losses

Our lives and the products and devices we use become more dependent on data by the day. As a result, cyberattacks and data breaches present everchanging risks to companies and individuals, and the importance...

Read More
News

Kelly Matayoshi Recognized With 2021 Outstanding Barristers Award

Read More
Publication

Cannabis Farms in the Neighborhood: Water, Contaminants and Other Proximate Matters

Farella's Buzz Hines, and guest speakers Kari Campbell-Bohard from EpicVeg and Lompoc Valley Cooling and Robert Schultz from Geo Blue Consulting, for a discussion on "Cannabis Farms in the Neighborhood: Water, Contaminants and Other...

Read More
Publication

Summary of Latest Federal Action Regarding PFAS

A few considerations practitioners should keep in mind when dealing with contamination involving per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) contamination. The PFAS Action Act of 2021 passed in the House and was received in the...

Read More
News

Chambers USA 2022 Recognizes Farella Braun + Martel Lawyers, Practices

Farella Braun + Martel is pleased to announce that Chambers USA has recognized 14 lawyers and 6 practice areas in the legal directory’s 2022 edition. Individual California and Western U.S. Rankings: Sarah Bell &ndash...

Read More
Publication

AB 525: Laying the Foundation for California's Offshore Wind Industry

Through Assembly Bill (AB) 525, California joined the flurry of activity in the offshore wind industry in 2021 led by the Biden Administration. While offshore wind development in California has lagged behind efforts on...

Read More
Event

The 15th Annual Santa Fe Advanced Conference on Litigating Natural Resource Damages

Jim Colopy is a speaker at the 15th Annual Santa Fe Advanced Conference on Natural Resource Damages on the panel addressing "Federal Jurisdiction: Waters of the United States.” 

Read More
News

John Ugai Joins ELI’s Emerging Leaders Initiative

Farella Braun + Martel is proud to announce that John Ugai, an associate in the firm’s Environmental Law and Energy + Infrastructure Industry groups, was selected to join the 2022 cohort of the Environmental...

Read More