Insights
Publications

Steep Fines for Company With Compliance Problems, but Recognition of Remediation Efforts May Provide Model Going Forward

December 6, 2016 Articles

After a series of compliance failures leading to the resignation of company’s CEO, the privately-held health care brokerage company Zenefits was just hit with a $7 million dollar settlement by the California Department of Insurance (DIR). The terms of the settlement may reflect a new trend in compliance enforcement, namely that regulators are trading monetary penalties for oversight over privately-held companies.

Founded in 2013 and once valued at $4.5 billion, Zenefits provides Human Resources and health care brokerage support to small businesses across the country. A few months ago we highlighted the San Francisco-based tech company’s efforts to develop an app to ensure the company’s compliance with state insurance brokerage laws, after a November 2015 report revealed that Zenefits failed to ensure that those of its employees acting as health insurance brokers were licensed to do so. Because Zenefits operated in all 50 states, it routinely had brokers assigned to projects for clients in states in which those brokers weren’t licensed to sell health insurance. Further reporting revealed that the company even created a special software program that let employees in California skip the mandatory 52 hour training sessions required for state certification.

The $7 million settlement with the California DIR is the largest in the country. The penalty consists of $3 million for licensing violations like allowing unlicensed employees to sell insurance products, $4 million in penalties for evading licensing education requirements, and $160,000 in reimbursement to the DIR for resources spent on its investigation.

However, in recognition of Zenefits’ extensive post-scandal efforts to reform the company’s culture and compliance regime, the DIR has agreed to suspend the payment of $3.5 million of the penalty if a 2018 audit of the company shows continued compliance with state regulations. This “carrot or stick” may reflect a new approach from compliance enforcers, namely that regulators are willing to accept smaller monetary awards in exchange for greater oversight over privately-held companies. When facing compliance-related enforcement actions, in the future privately-held companies should consider the degree of oversight they’re willing to trade for financial reward.

Zenefits has also settled claims for operating without a license in Arizona, Delaware, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Washington, as the internal investigation launched in response to the scandal revealed nationwide problems.

Firm Highlights

News

Sarah Good Appointed to California State Bar Board of Trustees

Read More
Publication

Internal Investigations for Nonprofits: A Means of Identifying and Addressing Misconduct Before the Regulators Come Calling

The worst nightmare for most nonprofit board members is a complaint that sparks an investigation of misconduct at the organization. The ember may have been burning for some time before the board becomes aware...

Read More
Publication

Cybersecurity Regulation: Key Takeaways From an Unusual FTC Order That Will Follow CEO for a Decade

The FTC recently issued a proposed order that would settle an enforcement action against Drizly, LLC and its co-founder and CEO, James Rellas, arising from data breaches in 2018 and 2020 that affected over...

Read More
Publication

A Primer for Corporate Directors: Maximizing Internal Investigation Effectiveness and Efficiency

In corporate America and across the globe, allegations of wrongdoing within companies are increasingly common, and the high cost of internal investigations continues apace.  In 2021, in an anonymous survey of more than 1,330...

Read More
Publication

Nonprofit Basics: Document Retention Policies and Subpoenas, and a Conversation With Aviva Gilbert on Why Good Policies Matter

Welcome to EO Radio Show – Your Nonprofit Legal Resource . This Nonprofit Basics episode covers record retention policies, document destruction schedules, and why they matter. You may have noticed that the IRS Form...

Read More
Publication

Uber’s Former Chief Security Officer Found Guilty of Obstruction For Coverup of Data Breaches

On October 5, 2022, after a monthlong jury trial, former Uber Chief Information Security Officer Joseph Sullivan was found guilty of obstructing proceedings of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and misprision of a felony...

Read More
News

Farella Names Carolina de Armas and Hilary Krase As Leadership Council on Legal Diversity Pathfinders

Carolina de Armas and Hilary Krase
Read More
Publication

The Humility To Prepare and the Confidence To Pull It off With Doug Young

Mike Herring interviews past ACTL President Doug Young in this episode of  Trial Tested: A Podcast by the American College of Trial Lawyers . S3E6: The Humility To Prepare and the Confidence To Pull It off With...

Read More
News

Aviva Gilbert Named a Leadership Council on Legal Diversity Fellow

Aviva Gilbert Headshot at Farella Braun + Martel
Read More
Publication

Maximizing Internal Investigation Effectiveness & Efficiency

In corporate America and across the globe, allegations of wrongdoing within companies are increasingly common, and the high cost of internal investigations continues apace. Companies are now also routinely investigating allegations beyond violations of...

Read More