Publications

Supreme Court Rules That Employees Can Waive Class Action Rights Through Arbitration Agreements

5/25/2018 Articles

On May 21, 2018, the United States Supreme Court ruled in Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis that arbitration agreements containing class action waivers are enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act. 584 U.S. ___ (Dkts. 16-285, 16-300, 16-307).

History

The U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed an employer’s ability to enforce arbitration agreements under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA).  But the U.S. Circuit Courts have split over whether employers could insist in those agreements that such arbitrations must be brought individually and not as class actions.  Some courts, including the Ninth Circuit, had held that class waiver provisions were prohibited by Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which protects employees’ right “to engage in…concerted  activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid and protection.” 

The Decision 

In 2017, the U. S. Supreme Court heard arguments for the following three cases: Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, Ernst & Young LLP v. Morris, and NLRB v. Murphy Oil USA, Inc.  All three cases presented the issue of whether class waivers were enforceable under the FAA.  For instance, Ernst & Young LLP v. Morris involved a junior accountant who had entered an arbitration agreement which included a class waiver but who then filed a misclassification class action in federal court, alleging that the class waiver was unenforceable. 

On May 21, 2018, the Supreme Court issued a long-awaited decision answering the question underlying all three cases.  Justice Gorsuch authored the majority decision, finding that the FAA’s saving clause (which excepts the enforcement of illegal agreements) did not preclude enforceability of class action waivers.  In part, the Court found that the saving clause’s general bases for rendering an agreement illegal only encompass defenses that could apply to any contract and do not include the argument that class waivers are illegal under the NLRA.  Moreover, the majority concluded that such an expansive interpretation of the saving clause would undermine the effect of the FAA overall.  The majority also opined that the language of NLRA Section 7 did not encompass protection for class and collective legal actions but rather was intended to protect the exercise of “the right to free association in the workplace.”  Epic, 584 U.S. ____, (Dkts. 16-285, 16-300, 16-307), slip op. at 12.

The Takeaway          

Now, Epic makes clear to employers that arbitration agreements containing class action waivers can effectively limit employees’ disputes to individualized actions.  As such, employers may offer arbitration agreements containing class action waivers at the outset of an employment relationship to avoid future collective actions.  However, when deciding whether to make use of such arbitration agreements, employers may also want to weigh the potential cumulative cost of multiple individual arbitrations – particularly given that employers in California normally must bear the cost of the arbitrator in such actions.  Employers should consult with legal counsel before determining whether arbitration clauses with class action waivers will advance their goals.

Firm Highlights

Publication

How to Navigate California Wage Statement Penalties After Naranjo v. Spectrum

On May 6, 2024, the California Supreme Court, in Naranjo v. Spectrum Security Services Inc. , clarified that an employer is not liable for statutory penalties for inaccurate wage statements when it had a...

Read More
News

Farella Advises TILT Holdings Inc. on $10.5M Loan Transaction

Northern California legal powerhouse Farella Braun + Martel advised TILT Holdings Inc. , a global provider of cannabis business solutions, and its Pennsylvania subsidiary, grower and processor Standard Farms, on a $10.5 million loan transaction...

Read More
News

Farella Braun + Martel Named Among 2024 Bay Area Best Places to Work

Read More
Publication

Advice for Nonprofit Investment Committees From an Investment Advisor

Welcome to  EO Radio Show - Your Nonprofit Legal Resource . In episode 82, we revisit the duties of directors in managing investment assets. Joining Cynthia Rowland today is Jennifer Nelson, Senior Wealth Manager...

Read More
Publication

7 Ways Companies and Content Creators Can Navigate Copyright Law for a Successful Partnership

In recent years, the advent of the social media “influencer” has revolutionized advertising. Companies often partner with influencers to market their products, hoping to tap into the influencer’s devoted audience. Likewise, influencers create certain content...

Read More
Publication

Nonprofit Book Review: ABA Guidebook for Directors of Nonprofit Corporations

Welcome to  EO Radio Show - Your Nonprofit Legal Resource . In today’s episode, Cynthia Rowland’s guest is Bill Boyd, one of the editors, along with Lisa Rundquist, of the newly published fourth edition of...

Read More
News

City of San Mateo Sued by Nonprofit Over New Housing Plan

Tom Mayhew spoke to CBS News about the lawsuit filed by Housing Action Coalition (HAC) and Farella against the City of San Mateo. The lawsuit challenges the city's recently adopted Housing Element in order to...

Read More
News

Chambers USA 2024 Recognizes Farella Braun + Martel Lawyers, Practices

Farella Braun + Martel is pleased to announce that Chambers USA has recognized 16 lawyers and six practice areas in the legal directory’s 2024 edition. Individual California and Western U.S. Rankings: Sarah Bell &ndash...

Read More
Publication

Nonprofit Quick Tip: State Filings in Oklahoma and Texas

Welcome to  EO Radio Show - Your Nonprofit Legal Resource . This is the 12th in a series of “Quick Tip” episodes focusing on the details of state registration of nonprofit corporations. In previous episodes, we...

Read More
News

Ex-DraftKings Exec Seeks Fast Trial To Test Noncompete Law

Holly Sutton, chair of Farella's Employment Law Group, provided expert commentary to Law360 for the article "Ex-DraftKings Exec Seeks Fast Trial To Test Noncompete Law." Read the article here (subscription required).

Read More